What’s the question?

What’s the question?

One of the best things about harp players is their innate curiosity (in the main). It has been my experience that we are, in general, interesting people who tend to be interested in loads of things.

But we’re also human and so sometimes we can do things that don’t move us forward. This is true whether we are teachers or students – where two sides of the same coin might be helpful and not!

For example, being curious. I think we’re all a little curious. That leads us to ask questions. Lots of questions.

Asking questions is imperative! It is a wonderful thing to ask questions. And we have a lot of resources – from teachers to friends to colleagues to learn from. Whether we know it or not, this searching for information to satisfy our curiosity helps us maintain a beginner’s mindset which has been celebrated as an important part of continuing personal growth. Beginners are curious because there is so much they don’t know! It is easy to stop being curious once you know some stuff. But no matter how much you know, there is always more to learn, to build on, to enhance, and to expand what we already have. Staying a beginner on the inside can be freeing because it allows you to give yourself permission to keep learning. A significantly experienced performer doesn’t have no questions. They have different questions! Hopefully, you are always coming up with questions as you learn.  Cultivating an interest is certainly one way to continue to push yourself – to be always learning. Sometimes the questions are simple and other times they are complex.

However, it is possible to confuse curiosity with diversion! I’m all for asking questions and learning, but focused questions based on your playing and learning are different from constantly scrolling fa-sta-gram-to-x watching videos and reading websites looking at content. That only draws in more information that fills your head but doesn’t actually inform you. Wasting time searching up info because it might be useful or getting into a loop of searching to search will never improve your playing. It won’t make you a better musician. And it will always leave you feeling like you should have learned more (and possibly like you have wasted time you could have been playing!).

I’m not suggesting there’s nothing of value to be learned online. But I am suggesting that letting your intuition, playing and experience drive your questions. And, you know that journal I’m always suggesting. That’s a great place to keep your questions so they don’t slip out of your head when you have a chance to ask them! Keep your questions focused on your development, your playing, your progress, and you’ll learn something every day!

Now, if there are no more questions? Go practice!

Where has your curiosity and questions led you? Let me know in the comments!

7 thoughts on “What’s the question?

  1. tho mostly a celtic player, i tried several styles. went to many workshops all over the place. in retrospect, i was scattered. i thought it was kinda Required to try Everything. Finally dumped the extraneous stuff, but i wasted a lot of time/effort that didn’t benefit me.

    • I’m pretty sure that it wasn’t a waste. It might not have appeared to get you where you thought you wanted to go, but I bet you learned a lot along the way.

  2. One of the questions that I find myself wrestling with and that sometimes pulls me from my harp is “ I wonder what the story behind this tune is”? I am fascinated by the history that surrounds the traditional tunes and knowing the story behind the tune can be so helpful in drawing a picture in my mind to aim for as I play. For example, I’m working on Leaving St Kilda right now, and the pictures of that story are so helpful to have inside my h art as I play. Other examples are Hector the Hero and Both Sides the Tweed. There are just enough rewarding stories out there o keep me looking but most of the time I come up empty and feeling like I should have just spent that time playing the tune…

    • You have a great point! Sometimes there is a clear story (like the ones you listed). Sometimes there are multiple stories out there (like MacIntosh’s Lament). When there is no evident story – you can make up your own! And if I’m not sure where to start, I check out recordings and decide from there.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.